Overcoming Writing Blocks & Reclaiming Your Purpose
Pre-tenure faculty face immense pressure to maintain steady productivity and keep publishing. Yet, after a few rejections, even dedicated scholars can stumble and begin to question their confidence.
Reframing Rejection: Anna’s Story
Anna came to coaching after experiencing a severe writing block that contributed to a negative performance review. A top journal had rejected a manuscript representing the work she was most passionate about, with editors stating the topic was not relevant to the field.
Because this piece reflected her core purpose—her most meaningful work—the rejection led her to believe that her field doubted her value as a scholar. Together, we examined whether a single decision by three editors could truly represent the entire discipline. We also confronted a crucial question: If the broader field did not yet value her work, would she stop doing it?
Rather than backing down, Anna redoubled her faith in her research. She realized part of her mission was to push the discipline to embrace broader perspectives and frameworks. Understanding that rejection is often an expected part of shifting a field, she anchored into her core conviction. Future rejections became fuel for her fire rather than a reason to extinguish it.
Silencing the Inner Critic: Eileen’s Story
Other faculty struggle with critical voices from their past. Despite earning a prestigious graduate fellowship and maintaining a 4.0 GPA, Eileen’s dissertation defense was exceptionally harsh. Her committee members raised sharp doubts about the rigor of her findings, accusing her of speaking from advocacy rather than data. Though she completed multiple revisions and passed, the experience left a scar.
Eileen went on to secure a plum tenure-track position surrounded by supportive colleagues. She successfully published collaborative projects, yet remained completely blocked when trying to write from her dissertation. Every time she sat down to draft a paper, her committee’s critical voices echoed in her head, telling her that her work failed to measure up.
We worked together to help Eileen spot her inner critic as soon as it emerged and pivot to healthier writing habits. We reconnected her to her foundational purpose and values—reminding her why she chose to become a researcher in the first place. We also helped her build a supportive community of colleagues for safe, constructive feedback, establish realistic productivity benchmarks, and identify journal outlets that would meaningfully advance her career.
How I Help
I offer actionable strategies to help faculty quiet their inner critics, build sustainable writing habits, and stay on track with their publishing goals.
